This page is part of the classification corrections guide, which covers what to inventory before a broker platform migration. Here the job is narrower: a decision tree you can walk through on one call to find who inside the company can say yes.
Why the integrator's view of the tables is not a yes
Trade systems integrators often know a client's correction history better than anyone. They mapped the entry tables, wired the ruling lookups and moved item master data between systems. That knowledge makes it tempting to treat the integrator's day-to-day contact, often an IT manager or a trade systems lead, as the person who decides. It is the wrong signal.
A classification correction leaves records written by several hands. The importer of record (IOR) has its analysts propose the new heading, a licensed customs broker checks it and files the revised entry, sometimes through a post summary correction (CBP's route for fixing an entry summary before liquidation) carrying reason codes and a free-text explanation, and an outside consultant may have written the memo that settled the question. Being able to query all of it says nothing about who may license any of it. Retention is a separate matter too: entry records are generally kept for five years from the date of entry under 19 CFR 163.4, an obligation to keep, not a permission to license.
Walk the tree: five questions in order
Ask these in sequence. Each answer names the next person to speak to, and the graphic shows the same path from the people who hold the records to the person who can sign.
- Who is your contact today? If it is IT, the integrator's own project lead or a classification analyst, ask one question: who is accountable for classification decisions and their audit trail? The answer is usually the trade compliance director or customs compliance manager.
- Will the compliance director convene? Ask whether they would sponsor an internal conversation about the company's correction history. If yes, they become the working contact. If no, stop; nobody else will carry it.
- Is the company the IOR or the broker? Importers usually control their own approvals and product facts. A brokerage holds records about its clients' business that are confidential under the broker regulations at 19 CFR 111.24 and may be shared only with the client's written authorization or the other listed exceptions. Note which side you are on.
- Which record classes are in play? Separate what the company wrote from what a broker or consultant wrote. Material authored by others goes to counsel before any discussion of scope.
- Who approves? The CEO, with general counsel advising. In a larger group, a parent company or private equity sponsor may hold approval rights over company information; add them if so.
Stop when you have a named convener and a named approver. That pair is the introduction.
Who decides for each record class
The table separates the person who can describe a record from the person who can decide whether it is discussed. It is a starting map for the call, not a legal opinion.
| Record class | Who can describe it | Who decides | Sign-off to expect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internal approvals and analyst emails | Compliance director | IOR, through counsel | Counsel review of privilege and personal data |
| Item master changes | ERP or product data owner | IOR | Trade-secret review of specifications |
| Corrected entries and correction filings | Broker or entry operations | IOR, with the broker's view | Confidentiality terms in the brokerage agreement |
| Broker notes and analyses | Broker's account lead | Depends on the brokerage agreement | Broker agreement and written client authorization where the broker discloses |
| Consultant classification memos | Compliance director | Engagement terms | Consultant's consent if the engagement reserves rights |
| Precedent citations | Classification analyst | IOR | Public rulings need no consent; the company's linking of rulings to parts is its own work |
Two rows move the most. Broker notes often contain the clearest reasoning and the most contested ownership. Consultant memos are frequently the final word on a hard product and frequently reserved by engagement terms; the tariff classification consultant guide explains why consultants should check their own terms before anything else.
Branches that need legal, broker or client sign-off
Three side branches change the scope without ending the conversation:
- Broker-held records. If the brokerage wrote or holds the record, expect its agreement to matter, and expect written client authorization before a broker discloses anything about a client's business.
- Records tied to an open matter. Corrections connected to a prior disclosure, a penalty case or an active protest stay out of any discussion until counsel says otherwise.
- Personal data in emails. Analyst and approver names in correction threads may be personal data where privacy law applies. That does not rule the records out; it decides who joins the call.
None of these is a reason to skip the introduction. They are reasons to flag the issue early in the referral brief template, so the rights review starts in the right place.
Two Illustrative paths through the tree
Both companies are fictional, invented for this page. Neither is a real case or a completed deal.
| Question | 300-person industrial parts importer | 210-person customs brokerage |
|---|---|---|
| Contact today | Integrator's IT counterpart | Brokerage operations manager |
| Convener | Director of trade compliance | Licensed broker who supervises classification |
| Company side | IOR | Broker |
| Side branch | Broker notes held on the broker's platform | Every client-specific record |
| Approver | CEO, with general counsel | CEO, with counsel and written authorization from each client whose records are included |
The IOR's path is short: one convener, one approver and one broker question. The brokerage's path is longer, because most of what it holds is about other companies' business. Its own classification methods and internal review workflow may still be worth a discussion. In both, the convener can describe volumes and years from reason-code counts and system reports, without anyone opening an entry. The system map helps them do that.
Where the answer stays unknown until SourceX reviews it
Once the approver agrees to talk, four questions remain open, and no partner should answer them in advance:
- Rights: which record classes, years and client IORs' material the company can license after broker, consultant and privacy checks.
- Scope and form: which classes are included and how they are de-identified.
- Demand: whether any buyer wants classification correction histories when SourceX reviews them.
- Terms: whether an offer follows, and its payout and schedule.
The introduced company needs 50+ full-time employees at peak (contractors excluded), documented operating history, rights to license and an authorized contact. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English. Partners sign the Channel Partner Agreement before submitting introductions; the first valid introduction within the 90-day window is credited when the company submits a verified application, and one partner is credited per company. Why data rights matter explains why the review comes first, the logistics and warehousing page covers the wider sector, and preparing for a joint call with a company sponsor helps once the convener agrees.
Next step
Refer a company. No cap on rewards. Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.
When the compliance director has agreed to convene and to bring in the CEO, who can say yes, register as a partner, confirm the company on who qualifies and read the program terms before making the introduction.