Who this is for, and what activity is being weighed
The readers are law firm alliance managers fielding lawyers' questions about SourceX, and regulated advisers, among them investment adviser representatives, registered representatives, CFP professionals, CPAs and consultants, whose clients ask them about licensing company records. The activity is telling a client company about SourceX's program, sometimes as a SourceX partner who could be paid.
SourceX's unsigned sample partner agreement describes the division in one line: "SourceX licenses directly from suppliers; Partner makes introductions." The terms add the fact that makes the line matter. A reward is a share of the compensation SourceX actually pays the company, and a lead, meeting or signed agreement alone earns nothing payable. A paid partner's interest therefore leans toward the deal closing, which is exactly where a recommendation would point. The company's own money is a separate matter. Section 4 of the terms reads: "The referral reward is paid separately by SourceX and is never deducted from the supplier's agreed compensation." That answers the client's question about cost. It does not answer the conflict question.
How three rule-makers draw the line for their own members
The CFP Board. Its Code and Standards define Financial Advice as "a communication that, based on its content, context, and presentation, would reasonably be viewed as a recommendation that the Client take or refrain from taking a particular course of action" on the subjects it lists. It calls the test "an objective rather than subjective inquiry," says "the more individually tailored the communication is to the Client, the more likely the communication will be viewed as Financial Advice," and lists among the subjects "the selection and retention of other persons to provide financial or Professional Services to the Client."
FINRA. For securities, its Notice to Members 01-23 treats whether a recommendation was made as an objective question that turns on a communication's content, context and manner of presentation, gives more weight to communications tailored to a specific customer, and notes that a series of steps can amount to a recommendation taken together (our paraphrase).
The ABA Model Rules. Rule 2.1 says a lawyer representing a client shall "exercise independent professional judgment and render candid advice," and allows that advice to draw on economic and other factors beyond the law (our paraphrase of the second sentence). A client who asks its lawyer whether to sign is asking for that kind of advice, and a possible reward would sit beside the answer.
These texts were written for their own members and subjects. Whether any of them reaches a data licensing introduction depends on your role, your firm and where you practice, and this page does not decide it. What they share is useful anyway: the CFP Board and FINRA both judge the communication as the client would reasonably hear it, and both give tailoring weight.
The recommendation boundary ladder
Seven steps, from a bare mention to acting in the deal. The wording is Illustrative.
| Step | What you say or do | How the client could hear it | Side of the line | Settle first |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "SourceX licenses records directly from companies for AI training; its site explains which companies it works with." | Information | Introduction | Nothing about the client leaves your file |
| 2 | "If this interests the company, it is your CEO's decision; the company can apply itself, or I can introduce your CEO." | Information with an offer | Introduction | The client's consent before its name goes to SourceX, and any reward disclosed |
| 3 | "Companies with a long operating history and records of their own are the kind SourceX describes." | A suggestion that this fits you | Tailoring begins | Use only what the CEO has told you openly, never the engagement file |
| 4 | "I think a call would be worth your time." | A mild call to act | Recommendation | Counsel or compliance first if you could be paid |
| 5 | "You should license." | A call to act on the transaction | Recommendation | Counsel or ethics adviser; often where a paid partner steps back |
| 6 | "That price and scope look fair; sign it." | Advice on the deal | Transaction advice | Engagement scope and advice from someone with no SourceX interest |
| 7 | Negotiating, signing or running the data handoff for the client | Representation | Outside the partner role | A separate engagement question entirely |
Steps 1 and 2 introduce. Step 3 is where a fitted reason starts turning information into a suggestion, the point at which both the CFP Board and FINRA texts give tailoring weight. Steps 4 and 5 recommend; steps 6 and 7 advise on or act in the transaction. The ladder sorts statements. It does not tell you which step your rules allow, and a series of small steps can climb it as surely as one large one. For wording that keeps an email at steps 1 and 2, see how to make an introduction without endorsing.
Confidentiality, conflict and compensation, step by step
| Question | Where it rises | Who answers it |
|---|---|---|
| What client information would leave your file, the client's name included? | Step 2 onward | You, under your confidentiality duties, with your counsel |
| Could privileged material or engagement work product travel with the introduction? | Never permitted at any step | Keep it out entirely |
| Could a possible reward limit the advice you give? | Steps 3 to 7, sharpest at 5 and 6 | Your counsel, compliance officer or ethics adviser |
| May you be paid at all, and how must it be disclosed? | Before step 2 | Your rule-maker, employer and adviser, never this page |
What you may tell SourceX about a client before an introduction is for your own confidentiality duties and your counsel to settle, and the client disclosure a finance advisor should review before referring sets out a disclosure draft to put to a reviewer. The introduction itself carries only what the CEO agreed to share, and the CEO, not you, decides whether the company talks to SourceX.
When the client's question pulls you up the ladder
Most drift happens in answer to a client, not in the first message. Four questions and replies that hold a step (Illustrative):
- "Would you do it if you were us?" "That is your CEO's decision. I can tell you what SourceX publishes and who you would speak to, but weighing the deal is not my role here."
- "Is their price fair?" "I have not reviewed it and cannot judge it. Counsel with no tie to SourceX can."
- "Can you just handle it for us?" "That would be a separate engagement, and my firm would have to consider it before I could agree."
- "Do you get something if we sign?" "SourceX may pay me a reward if your company licenses and is paid. SourceX pays it separately, and it does not come out of what the company receives."
If the company wants its lawyer to look at the program first, when a client wants to talk to a lawyer first covers that pause.
Three cases and where each ended (Illustrative)
A referral. A 60-lawyer firm's alliance manager takes the ladder to ethics counsel, who clears a disclosed, paid introduction limited to steps 1 and 2, on the condition that the firm will not advise those clients on a SourceX deal. The firm signs the Channel Partner Agreement as an entity; SourceX's sample names the partner as "an individual, or entity type and jurisdiction." A client CEO says yes to a conversation, and the alliance manager sends the step 2 message with the reward disclosed.
An unpaid introduction. A CFP professional's firm reads the CFP Board definition and decides, for its own staff, to keep client conversations about SourceX to steps 1 and 2 with no reward. SourceX's published terms do not settle how a partner who turns a reward down is handled, so she asks SourceX in writing before submitting anything. The client's CEO decides to talk, and she introduces unpaid.
No part at all. Outside counsel already advising a company on its customer contracts is asked by the CEO whether to sign SourceX's offer, a step 6 question. The firm decides to give that advice under its engagement and to take no part in SourceX's program for this client, so no introduction and no reward follow.
Record the step you stayed on
Write a few lines in your own file after any SourceX conversation with a client: the highest step reached, the date, who cleared it, what went to whom (the CEO, SourceX) and what stayed out (privileged material, client records, engagement work). Keep the note free of the client's records; it documents your conduct, not the company.
Next step
Refer a company. No cap on rewards. Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.
If your adviser clears steps 1 and 2 and the CEO wants the conversation, register as a partner, send only what who qualifies already publishes, and read the program terms before the step 2 message goes out. Related professional guides sit in the guides library.