An M&A advisor or business broker often sees both the buyer's memo and the seller's records. The useful work is to screen the memo's data lines with the target's CEO, mark each one documented, assumed or contradicted, and keep every licensing idea out of the price and out of the teaser.
What a deal memo can say about records, and what it cannot
Buyer decks and investment memos now describe a target's operating history as a "data asset": a decade of proprietary records, a moat, an option to license to AI developers. Each of those lines is the buyer's reading of property that, on the day the memo is written, belongs to someone else.
A thesis cannot do three things:
- Create ownership. Records belong to whoever created them or took them over in a signed writing, not to whoever finds them interesting.
- Move ownership. What passes at closing passes through the purchase documents. The memo conveys nothing.
- Authorize a conversation. The program needs the company's CEO to agree to a licensing discussion. A buyer's deal team is not that person before closing, and SourceX's screening guidance treats an introduction made without the decision maker's knowledge as usually not a fit.
The advisor's discipline follows from those limits. A thesis line never travels into a referral note, a teaser or a price adjustment. SourceX publishes no conversion rates, and a company's payout is fixed only in a signed Dataset Deal Confirmation, so any number attached to a thesis was made up by whoever wrote it.
Whose yes counts, and when it moves
Authority changes hands once, at closing. Before it, the target's CEO decides whether the company discusses licensing, even with a letter of intent or a signed purchase agreement in place; deal counsel reads whether those documents give the acquirer a consent right over new contracts. After closing, SourceX's screening guidance says plainly that the acquirer's CEO decides for an acquired company.
The thesis author never decides: not the deal partner, the corporate development lead or the operating partner who wrote the data line. If someone on the acquirer's side contacts SourceX about a company it does not yet own, that is not an introduction by the company's decision-maker. Under section 2 of the terms, credit is settled from dated records, and section 3 treats a company SourceX already has a relationship with as a duplicate. How an acquirer's earlier inquiry bears on a later introduction is SourceX's call when it reviews duplicates; no published rule covers it.
The thesis-versus-ownership screening guide
Take every sentence in the memo that mentions records, data or AI. Run each through five tests in order, and stop at the first failure; a later test cannot rescue an earlier one.
| Test | The question | What answers it | Who supplies the answer | It fails when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Authorship | Who created these records? | The target CEO's account of which teams wrote them, plus contractor and client agreements | The target's CEO, with counsel on the agreements | Clients, contractors or other third parties wrote them and nothing in writing gives their rights to the target |
| 2. Transfer | After this deal, will the rights sit with the entity that would license them? | The deal form, and the agreement's records and IP clauses | Deal counsel | An asset deal leaves the records, or the rights in them, with the seller |
| 3. Promises | What did the target tell customers and users about their data? | Privacy policy, customer contracts and terms of service | Counsel | A promise rules out the new use and nobody has addressed consent |
| 4. Prior licensing | Has any of this been licensed for AI training already? | A contract list and the CEO's answer | The target's CEO | Yes, for the records in question |
| 5. Authority today | Who can say yes on the date of the ask? | Where the deal stands on the calendar | The advisor | The person asking is not the CEO of the entity that holds the records |
Each line then gets one mark. Documented means a signed document or the CEO's dated answer supports it. Assumed means plausible but unsupported. Contradicted means a document says otherwise. Only documented lines may be repeated to anyone, and only with the target CEO's approval.
Why authorship comes first. Under 17 U.S.C. 201(b), for a work made for hire "the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author." Notes and logs that staff wrote in the course of their jobs start out as the company's. Files that clients uploaded, paperwork carriers submitted or reports a contractor delivered do not start there, and SourceX's screening guidance lists material belonging to a company's clients among the usual misfits.
Why transfer is a document question. Section 204(a) of the same title says a transfer of copyright ownership, other than by operation of law, "is not valid unless an instrument of conveyance, or a note or memorandum of the transfer, is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights conveyed or such owner's duly authorized agent." A memo is not that instrument. In a share deal the target keeps its own records and only its owners change; in an asset deal, what moves is what the agreement conveys. How either statute applies to a particular deal is for counsel, not for the advisor.
Why promises can override a plan. When Facebook proposed to buy WhatsApp in 2014, the FTC's consumer protection bureau told both companies that WhatsApp's privacy promises would still apply after the acquisition, and that materially changing how already-collected data was used would need users' affirmative consent (a paraphrase of the FTC's announcement). A thesis that assumes a new owner can repurpose customer data has skipped this test.
Why prior licensing ends the discussion. In SourceX's own process, the supplier confirms it holds the rights, that personal data was collected lawfully, that the data "hasn't been licensed for AI training before" and that it was not created or altered with AI for the sale. A target that already licensed its history to an AI developer has nothing left to offer on those records, whatever the memo projects.
Keep the buyer's paper out of any introduction
Advisors see paper from both sides. The acquirer's model, its investment memo, bid letters, the data room index and the quality-of-earnings work all stay inside the transaction. If the target's CEO wants a conversation with SourceX, the introduction carries only what that CEO approves in writing: record types, systems, rough year spans, the peak full-time headcount and the CEO's own contact details. The advisor never sends files, samples or system access, and the first step does not ask for any.
One test before anything is sent: could the target's CEO have written this sentence without seeing the buyer's materials? If not, it stays behind. When an acquirer asks the advisor to "line up" a licensing conversation before closing, the answer is that the target decides, and the request goes no further.
An asset deal, screened week by week (Illustrative)
Illustrative. A generic target and acquirer with invented facts; no outcome is implied.
A regional logistics platform agrees to buy the operating assets of a 230-person freight brokerage whose founder is still its CEO. The platform's memo calls eleven years of load, exception and claims history "a licensable data asset to pursue after close."
| Week | Deal event | What the screen found |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Letter of intent signed | The sell-side advisor reads the memo's data line and repeats it to nobody |
| 2 | Advisor meets the brokerage's CEO | Test 1: dispatcher notes and exception logs written by staff are documented; shipper documents and carrier paperwork are contradicted |
| 3 | The CEO checks the contract list | Test 4: a 2023 agreement licensed de-identified load data to an analytics vendor; until counsel reads whether it reached AI training, those records are assumed |
| 5 | Counsel reviews the draft agreement | Test 2: books, records and related IP are purchased assets; the seller keeps copies for tax and legal use only |
| 6 | Customer terms reviewed | Test 3: shipper contracts limit shipment data to providing the service, so that family is out |
| 10 | Closing | Test 5: the acquirer's CEO now decides; the advisor hands over the dated screen, never the memo |
Of the memo's four data lines, one survived as documented and transferring (the staff-written exception and dispatch notes), one stayed assumed (the 2023 license) and two were contradicted. No figure appears anywhere. The pre-closing work was done with the brokerage's CEO because that CEO held the decision on those dates.
If the acquirer's CEO later wants to explore, the brokerage and its new parent count as one company for the reward cap, which matters to a platform that may introduce other businesses in the same group. The program's fit facts still apply on their own terms: 50 or more full-time employees at peak with contractors excluded, several years of the company's own records, and rights to license them. The program's home page notes that operating, acquired or wound down companies can all qualify, and not every company does.
Where the screen misleads
- Drafting decides. Records clauses, IP assignments and retained-copy provisions vary by deal. The screen points at the clause; counsel reads it.
- Two U.S. statutes. The copyright sections quoted above are U.S. federal law. A target elsewhere sits under other rules, which local counsel supplies.
- Privacy is wider than promises. The FTC letter concerns keeping promises already made. Other privacy laws can restrict personal data whatever a company promised.
- Demand is not tested here. Passing all five tests says nothing about whether the records match a current SourceX program. That is decided in SourceX's review, and a company that misses one program may fit another later.
- A screen dates quickly. A signed amendment or a newly found contract can flip a mark. Date every mark and redo the screen when the deal documents change.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Next step
Refer a company. No cap on rewards. Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.
When a screened line is documented and the CEO who holds the decision on that date wants a conversation, sign up through partner registration, hold the company up to the published screening profile once more and go through the program terms before the idea leaves the deal team. The records questions themselves are worked clause by clause in who owns business records after an asset sale and asset sale versus stock sale; advisors new to the program can start with the overview for M&A advisors and the note on post-acquisition opportunities, or browse every guide.