This page is for fractional CFOs, outsourced controllers and accounting practice leaders who hold equity in a client, directly, through a vehicle or through family. It gives no legal or professional-conduct advice; those answers come from your firm, your state board or society, or your counsel.
Two interests that push in one direction
Most conflicts pull an adviser two ways. This one pushes one way. As a shareholder you benefit from anything that adds to what the company receives. As a SourceX partner you could be paid the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of what SourceX actually pays the company, with no cap for the company and its whole group. The terms keep the two amounts apart: section 4 says "The referral reward is paid separately by SourceX and is never deducted from the supplier's agreed compensation." Your reward never comes out of the company's payout, and the company receives the same amount whether you are paid or not.
That separation protects the company's money. It does not protect your judgment. When the CEO asks you, as the company's finance advisor, whether licensing records now is sensible, both interests lean toward yes, and the CEO may know about only one of them. The advisory role here is to give the CEO a view the CEO can weigh; the benefit to the client is an introduction made with every interest on the table, so the CEO can discount your enthusiasm by the right amount.
Six hats an advisor-investor can wear at one company
Count every hat, including the ones you rarely think about.
| Hat | What it gives you | What it never gives you | Who should know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct shareholder | A share of any value the company gains | A say in whether the company licenses | The CEO, in your disclosure |
| Holder through a vehicle someone else manages | An indirect stake | A reason to leave the stake out of your disclosure | The CEO; your rule-maker may count it too |
| Director or board observer | A voice in the boardroom and the board papers | The power to open a licensing discussion | The CEO, and the board under its own policies |
| Finance advisor or fractional CFO | Working knowledge of the finances and systems | The CEO's decision or signature | The CEO |
| Audit or review provider, you or your firm | Engagement access | Any use of that access for an introduction | Your firm's independence function, first |
| Registered SourceX partner | A possible reward if a valid introduction is credited | Any power to commit SourceX to prices or payouts | The CEO, in plain words |
Family holdings are a hat too. The AICPA's Plain English Guide to Independence says "your immediate family (your spouse or equivalent and dependents) generally needs to follow the same guidance you're required to follow as a covered member."
The boardroom hat carries its own rule. Whatever you learn from board papers may prompt one question to that company's own CEO; it never travels to anyone else, SourceX included, and it never reaches a different company. SourceX's screening page makes the related point that a board seat gives a voice in the boardroom without the power to start a licensing discussion.
The dual-role conflict review worksheet
Fill it in before you mention SourceX to anyone at the company. Keep it in your own files. Line 6 is the only part the CEO reads, and it is written last.
| Line | Question | Example answer (Illustrative) | Who confirms |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Every role you hold at the company, with start dates | Fractional CFO since 2023; 2% shareholder from a 2022 angel round | You, from your own records |
| 2 | Roles your immediate family or your firm hold there | None; the firm provides no audit or review work | Your firm |
| 3 | What each role gains if the company licenses data | Shares: any added value; partner: a possible reward from SourceX | You |
| 4 | What each role taught you, and whether it may be used | System names known from the engagement, used only to frame one question to the CEO | You; your rule-maker if unsure |
| 5 | The rule-maker for each role | State board and firm policy for the advisory work; the company's own policy for any board seat | Each rule-maker, in writing |
| 6 | The disclosure the CEO will read | "I own shares in the company and SourceX could pay me if you license data. The decision is yours, and you would receive the same amount either way." | You, after line 5 is answered |
| 7 | Who would sign as partner, if anyone | You, your firm or nobody | SourceX, against its agreement |
| 8 | What you will step back from | Advising on whether to accept any offer the company receives | You and the CEO |
| 9 | The route the CEO chose, and the date | The paid route, by the CEO's email of 20 October | The CEO |
Line 7. SourceX's sample Channel Partner Agreement names the partner as "an individual, or entity type and jurisdiction", so a firm can sign rather than a person. SourceX credits one partner per company. How a firm's partner account sits beside accounts its own people hold is something the published terms leave open, and SourceX settles it.
Line 8. Stepping back from part of your advice is your choice, not a rule this page sets. Whether your rules ask for more, or for less, is your adviser's call.
Line 6, last. Written before line 5 is answered, a disclosure tends to promise more than your rules allow. Written after, it says only what you know to be true.
Independence, objectivity and pay: which rule-maker reads each hat
Each hat answers to a different rule-maker, and the answers follow the services you or your firm provide and where you are licensed.
- Independence, for CPAs. The AICPA's Code defines a direct financial interest as "A financial interest that is owned directly by an individual or entity, including those managed on a discretionary basis by others." Whether a holding like yours affects independence depends on the services your firm performs for the client, so put it to your firm's independence function or ethics adviser before anything else. If your firm audits or reviews the company, the engagement separation map comes first.
- Objectivity and conflicts. The same Code pairs its "Integrity and Objectivity Rule" (1.100.001) with a "Conflicts of Interest for Members in Public Practice" interpretation (1.110.010). Read both with your adviser before settling what line 6 must say.
- Pay. State boards set their own rules on commissions and referral fees, and some may leave no room for a reward at all. The applicable-rules checklist works through them by service and state, and the reviewed client disclosure turns the answer into words the client keeps.
- Advisers who are not CPAs. Your engagement letter, any firm policy and your own counsel are the rule-makers, along with any employer whose approval you need.
Three routes the CEO can approve, one company payout
- The company goes alone. You tell the CEO that SourceX exists, disclose both interests and step out. The company applies itself and no partner is named, so no reward is paid to anyone.
- You introduce, paid. Your adviser has answered on line 5, you hold an approved partner account, you signed the Channel Partner Agreement before submitting, and the CEO has read line 6 and wants the conversation. You submit; the company applies and describes its own records.
- You introduce, unpaid. You want to make the introduction and take nothing. The published terms do not cover a declined reward, so ask SourceX in writing how it would treat your introduction before you submit, and repeat its answer to the CEO in its own words. The unpaid path for finance professionals sets out the order; an investor helping through a fund has a separate set of routes.
In all three the company's payout is the same. Only the partner line differs, and the sample agreement bars a partner from committing SourceX to any price or payout, so none of the three routes carries a promise to the company.
Three advisor-investors, three worksheets (Illustrative)
Illustrative, with generic people and invented facts.
A fractional CFO with a small stake. She advises a 180-person field-services company and holds 2% from an early angel round; her firm does no audit or review work. Lines 1 to 5 take an afternoon and one written answer from her own adviser. Her disclosure goes to the CEO by email, the CEO asks to hear more, and she submits under route 2. She leaves the decision on any offer to the CEO and the company's counsel.
A CPA whose spouse holds shares. His firm reviews the company's annual statements, and his spouse owns shares bought years ago. Line 2 stops the worksheet: the firm's independence function is the first call, not the CEO. The firm takes no part in any introduction. Months later the CEO hears of SourceX elsewhere and the company applies on its own.
An adviser with a board observer seat. She learns from board papers that the company is retiring an old ticketing system. Under line 4 that knowledge can prompt one question to the CEO, and nothing more. The CEO says not this year. The worksheet records the date and the event the CEO named as a reason to talk again.
Where a conflict worksheet stops working
- Recording is not removing. The worksheet makes a conflict visible; it does not make it go away.
- Disclosure may not be enough. Some rules may bar a reward however clearly it is disclosed. Your adviser says which.
- Groups. A company inside a group shares one reward cap with its parent and sister companies.
- Earlier contact. If the company already had a lead, account or email exchange with SourceX, section 3 treats it as a duplicate credited to no later partner, whatever your roles.
- Control. If the company is sold, the target's CEO decides until closing and the acquirer's CEO afterward; in a deadlocked 50/50 ownership, or under a trustee or court, the CEO alone may not be enough.
- No data. Nobody has published how CEOs respond to a dual-role disclosure, or whether it changes their decision.
Next step
Refer a company. No cap on rewards. Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.
When line 6 has reached the CEO and the CEO has chosen a route, register if that route involves you, test the company against who qualifies and read the program terms on duplicates and credit; related finance-advisor guides are in the guides hub.