The question is the firm's, not one lawyer's, because promotion runs at firm level. A client alert, a seminar slide or a line on the firm's website speaks for every lawyer and reaches every client, including the ones a corporate partner may later advise on a license. One careful lawyer cannot fix a firm-wide message after it has gone out.
Why the alliance manager cannot answer it alone
A law firm is the natural adviser on the very transaction it would be promoting. Whether a company owns its records, what its customer contracts allow and whether the agreement with SourceX is acceptable are legal questions, and a business firm's corporate group may well be the team a client calls about them. If the same firm is paid when that client's deal completes, it holds an interest in the outcome of advice it is giving. The ABA's comment to Model Rule 1.7 names, as an example of business interests that can affect a representation, referring clients to an enterprise in which the lawyer has an undisclosed financial interest (our paraphrase of the ABA text).
The reward mechanics matter to that analysis, and ethics counsel should see them exactly. Under section 4 of SourceX's terms (version 2026-10-22.2, since replaced by version 2026-11-04) the default reward is the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of the Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap across all agreements, and section 4 also says "The referral reward is paid separately by SourceX and is never deducted from the supplier's agreed compensation." Section 5 adds: "A lead, meeting or signed agreement alone does not earn a payable reward." Put plainly, a reward exists only if the client's deal completes and SourceX pays the client, which is why the firm's role in that deal is the first item on the agenda.
The rule texts that go in front of ethics counsel
Four sources belong in the review pack, each read in the version that binds the lawyers concerned; the ABA publishes model rules, and ethics counsel decides which adopted text governs each lawyer. Nothing here is legal advice.
- Confidentiality. ABA Model Rule 1.6(a) reads: "A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client gives informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized in order to carry out the representation or the disclosure is permitted by paragraph (b)."
- Personal-interest conflicts. Model Rule 1.7 treats a significant risk that a representation will be materially limited by the lawyer's own interest as a concurrent conflict, and where such a conflict can proceed with consent, that consent is confirmed in writing (our paraphrase of the ABA text).
- Public promotion. The FTC's Endorsement Guides, at 16 CFR 255.5, call for clear and conspicuous disclosure of a connection the audience would not expect when it could affect how much weight they give an endorsement, and they count business, family and personal relationships as well as payment (our paraphrase).
- SourceX's own agreement. The sample Channel Partner Agreement says neither party may publicly identify the other as a partner without written authorization (section 4.5), and gives the partner no authority to share a supplier's records, raw data or personal information (section 4.2).
The professional-rule review agenda
Seven items, taken in order, because the first answer changes how much of the rest matters. The alliance manager brings the facts in the third column from SourceX's published pages; ethics counsel answers; the last column is what the firm writes down.
| Item | Question for the review | Facts the alliance manager brings | What the firm records |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Counsel and introducer | Will the firm accept engagements to advise companies it introduced, on their rights or on their agreement with SourceX? | The reward is the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of what SourceX actually pays the company, with no cap, and nothing is payable without a completed deal | The firm's posture: paid route, unpaid mention or no part |
| 2. Who would sign | Would the firm sign as the partner, or would individual lawyers? | The sample agreement names the partner as "an individual, or entity type and jurisdiction"; the published terms do not say how a firm's account relates to its lawyers' own accounts, so SourceX decides that | One signatory, and that open point put to SourceX in writing |
| 3. Channels | Client alerts, seminars, the website, or one-to-one conversations only? | Section 4.5 of the sample agreement on naming the other party as a partner; the FTC guides on material connections | Approved channels, and disclosure wording counsel has signed off |
| 4. Information boundary | What may leave the firm about a client, and with whose consent? | Rule 1.6(a); SourceX's process page says an introducer need not export, upload or describe confidential records; section 4.2 of the sample agreement | Client identity only as counsel directs; client and privileged material never |
| 5. Conflicts on SourceX's side | Is SourceX, or anyone the firm can identify on its side, a client or an adverse party? | The Acquisition Partner's identity and contract may remain confidential (sample agreement, section 1.9) | How the conflicts check handles parties the firm cannot see |
| 6. Who decides at each client | Whom does the firm approach? | The CEO authorizes a licensing discussion and signs for the company; a general counsel or CFO may advise or prepare the case | Introductions go to the CEO, or through someone the CEO trusts |
| 7. Review date | When is the decision revisited, and by whom? | Terms version 2026-10-22.2, since replaced by version 2026-11-04 and its change log; the agreement runs one year and renews only with fresh signatures (terms, section 9) | A named owner and a date |
Three firms, three endings (Illustrative)
Illustrative. Generic firms with invented facts; each ending reflects that firm's own counsel applying its own rules, and none says what any rule allows.
Firm A, a 70-lawyer business firm. Its corporate group drafts commercial contracts for dozens of mid-sized companies and expects clients to ask it about data licenses. On item 1 the firm decides, with its ethics counsel, to keep its role as counsel and take no reward. Ending: an unpaid mention. Lawyers tell a client's CEO the option exists when it is relevant, the company applies on its own, and nothing about the client leaves the firm.
Firm B, a litigation boutique. It rarely touches clients' commercial agreements and will not take engagements on data licenses. Its ethics counsel works through items 2 to 6 and sets conditions: written disclosure to each client, consent before any client is named, and no lawyer at the firm advising an introduced company on its license. The firm signs as the entity partner. Ending: a referral route, on counsel's conditions.
Firm C, a firm with a technology practice. Its technology group acts for AI developers and data businesses. Item 5 cannot be closed, because the Acquisition Partner on SourceX's side may stay confidential. Ending: no part. Its lawyers answer client questions about licensing as counsel only, and the firm records why.
Which clients a firm-wide promotion would concern
Most of a firm's clients will not fit, which is one more reason to decide before promoting widely. SourceX's published fit facts call for a full-time headcount of 50 or more at the company's peak, contractors not counted, years of operating records the company made itself, the right to license those records and a CEO keen to talk. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English.
Material that belongs to a company's own clients is usually not a fit, and an introduction made without the decision maker's knowledge usually is not either. Privileged material and client files never travel with an introduction in any direction. Three neighboring questions belong to other pages and other roles: whether the firm could license its own operational records is covered in can law firms use client data to train AI; a client worried that licensing makes it a data broker needs the state-law data broker explainer and its own counsel; and change-in-law clauses in a license are the company's counsel's work, mapped in what happens if AI law changes after licensing.
What the agenda cannot settle
The agenda organizes a decision; it does not make one. Rules differ by jurisdiction, and a firm with lawyers admitted in several places may get different answers for different offices. A written disclosure, on its own, may not settle whether compensation is permitted; that is for counsel. Facts change by client, so a firm that chose a paid route still checks each introduction against items 4 and 6. SourceX's terms carry a version number and a change log, and the agreement runs a year, so the decision needs its review date. And the open points the published terms leave to SourceX, such as how a firm's account relates to its lawyers', should be asked in writing before anyone signs.
When the firm chooses the unpaid mention, consent questions remain; an unpaid introduction can still require client consent works through them. Other partner decisions are in the partner guides.
Next step
Refer a company. No cap on rewards. Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.
If the firm's review ends in a referral route, the signatory named under item 2 should register as a partner and sign the Channel Partner Agreement before any introduction; in every ending, check client fit against who qualifies and give ethics counsel the current program terms.