# Preserving evidence vs licensing an archive | SourceX

Canonical: https://refer.sourcex.si/guides/the-difference-between-preserving-evidence-and-monetizing-an-archive
Last updated: 2026-11-04

Preservation and licensing are two decisions with two owners. Records kept as evidence are kept because a legal duty or counsel says so, for a scope counsel sets. Whether a company's records are ever licensed is a commercial decision for its CEO, or for whoever controls the estate if the company has closed. Keep them apart: an introducer's licensing hope is never a reason to keep records past their date or to discard them early, and a preservation file is never an inventory of what could be sold. Settle preservation first, then ask the decider once.

The two get confused because they often concern the same boxes, servers and people, and because restructurings and wind-downs bring both questions at once. This page is about the line between them. What to do while a litigation hold is actually in place is covered in [when a litigation hold reaches an archive conversation](/questions/litigation-hold-records-can-they-be-shared).

## Two purposes, two owners, two clocks

| Dimension | Preserving evidence | Considering a license |
|---|---|---|
| Why the records sit as they do | A hold, a claim, a regulator's requirement or an estate's administration | The company's own operating history |
| Who sets the scope | Counsel, for the matter or duty | The CEO or the estate's controller, with rights settled in SourceX's review |
| What defines the edges | Custodians, date ranges and record types counsel names | Record families the company chooses to offer |
| How long it lasts | Until counsel releases it or the duty ends | The decider's own timing; credit for an introduction runs on a 90-day window |
| Copies made | Whatever counsel directs, by whoever counsel directs | None by any introducer |
| Who may be told what | Counsel decides | The decider decides |
| The introducer's part | None, beyond passing the decider a date | One question to the decider |

The rows rarely conflict on paper. They conflict in conversation: records the company must keep anyway start to look like something to offer, or a lifted hold becomes a reason to value records before they go. Either way, one purpose is steering the other.

## Three names before the first question

Three names, each with the date you checked:

- **The decider.** The CEO of an operating company; after an acquisition, the acquirer's CEO. For a closed or insolvent company, SourceX's screening page says the CEO alone may not be enough, and whoever controls the estate decides: a trustee, receiver or assignee in a formal process.
- **Preservation counsel.** The lawyer who knows which duties apply and when each ends.
- **The holder.** The company itself, a storage vendor, an e-discovery provider or a former IT firm. Holding a copy decides nothing, as [an archive custodian is not always the licensing decision-maker](/guides/an-archive-custodian-is-not-always-the-licensing-decision-maker) explains.

When the three are different people, the introducer speaks only to the first, and only after the first has heard from the second.

## The preservation-first decision guide

Seven questions in a fixed order. Each has one owner, and a later question is never asked to get round an earlier answer.

| # | Question | Who answers | If the answer is yes or unsure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Is any preservation duty live over these records? | Counsel | Licensing waits; nothing about the records is discussed outside counsel's scope |
| 2 | Is what we are discussing a copy made for a matter: a collection, review set, production or forensic image? | Counsel | Leave it out; an introduction describes the company's own records |
| 3 | When the duty ends, does the company's retention schedule call for disposal? | Whoever owns the schedule | Disposal follows the schedule, whatever anyone hopes about licensing |
| 4 | Would anyone keep records past their date only because licensing came up? | The decider, with counsel | Stop: a licensing hope is not a retention reason the introducer can offer |
| 5 | Do the records hold personal data of people in the EU? | The company's privacy counsel | Whether a license fits the purpose the data was kept for is a question for that counsel |
| 6 | Who decides about licensing today? | Named from the screening page's rules | The CEO, the acquirer's CEO or the estate's controller |
| 7 | Does that decider want the conversation? | The decider | No-copy introduction; if no, a dated stop |

Question 5 rests on a principle, not a verdict. In paraphrase, Article 5(1)(b) of the EU's General Data Protection Regulation sets a purpose limitation principle: personal data are gathered for specified purposes, and later use must not be incompatible with them. The article's principles apply together, including a storage limitation principle. Records preserved for a lawsuit were kept for that lawsuit; whether licensing them is compatible is not something an introducer can judge.

**Method note.** The seven questions come from SourceX's screening page, its program terms and the unsigned sample agreement, read on 2026-10-28, plus one EU regulation quoted in paraphrase. They describe an order of questions, not legal conclusions, and give no preservation or privacy advice. The guide has not been tested on real archives, and SourceX has published no figures on how often preserved records are later licensed.

## The moments when the two purposes collide

| Moment | What preservation says | What a licensing conversation may do | The trap |
|---|---|---|---|
| A hold is in place | Counsel's scope governs every copy | Wait | Describing held records "just at a high level" |
| The hold is released | The schedule takes over again | Proceed only if the decider wants to, with whatever the company keeps for its own reasons | Asking the company to delay disposal until SourceX has looked |
| A retention period ends | The schedule says what happens next | The same | Treating the end of a duty as the start of a sale |
| An estate keeps records for claims | The estate's controller decides, with counsel | Asked once, of the controller | Approaching the former CEO because they know the systems |
| A provider still holds a matter's collection | It is a copy made for the matter | Nothing; it is not the archive | Accepting a provider's offer to "share the processed set" |

When a restructuring brings a filing, an appointment or a sale process, the pause rules in [when a restructuring team needs to pause licensing discussions](/guides/when-a-restructuring-team-needs-to-pause-licensing-discussions) apply on top of this table.

## Sending the introduction, or closing the file on the guide's answer

An introduction sent after the guide carries the decider's name and role with the date checked, the company's fit facts in the decider's words, the record families as the company describes them, and a line that nothing has been opened, copied or moved. It says nothing about any matter unless the decider chooses to. The sample Channel Partner Agreement states the copy rule plainly at section 4.4: "Partner must not collect or retain supplier dataset copies through the referral program without separate written authorization."

Write a dated stop note instead when counsel has not released the records, the only records in view are copies made for a matter, the conversation depends on keeping something past its date, no decider can be named, or the decider declines. The note records the company, the date, the question that stopped it and who was told. For an estate, the stop memo in [the data referral question for a liquidation advisor](/guides/the-data-referral-question-for-a-liquidation-advisor) serves the same purpose.

## Two archives, one line (Illustrative)

Illustrative. Invented companies and facts; no outcome implied.

**A released hold and a destruction date.** A 210-person claims administrator kept 2017 to 2020 claim files under a litigation hold that counsel released in the spring. Its schedule calls for destroying files older than seven years at year-end. A restructuring adviser who knows the CEO had mentioned SourceX months earlier, and the CEO asks whether she should hold the files back for a licensing review. The adviser's answer is that the schedule and counsel decide, not the referral. The company follows its schedule. Later the CEO asks to hear about SourceX for the records the company keeps in the ordinary course, and the adviser sends a no-copy introduction describing those.

**A processed set at a provider.** After a commercial dispute ends, the e-discovery provider for a 400-person distributor offers the company's restructuring adviser the processed, already indexed set. The adviser declines, tells the CEO the offer was made, and describes nothing from it. The set was built for the dispute; what the company decides about its own records is a separate conversation.

## Fit, credit and reward once both questions are settled

Once preservation is settled, the ordinary checks apply: a peak of 50 or more full-time employees, not counting contractors; a long run of records the business made for itself; rights to license that material without breaching anyone's confidentiality or contracts; a decider who agrees to talk; and relevance to a program SourceX is running now. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English.

The introducer signs the Channel Partner Agreement before submitting, and one partner is credited per company. Any reward is the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of what SourceX actually pays the company, with no cap for the company and its corporate group, paid separately and never taken from the company's payout. No figure for what an archive is worth, or when anything would be paid, can be given before SourceX's review; why that matters in a restructuring is covered in [referring a business in restructuring without promising recovery value](/guides/how-to-refer-a-business-in-restructuring-without-promising-recovery-value).

## When the purpose line blurs

- **Duties overlap.** One set of records can sit under a hold, a regulatory period and an estate's administration at once; question 1 is answered for all of them, not the first one found.
- **Counsel's release can be partial.** A release may cover some custodians or years and not others.
- **Schedules are imperfect.** A company may find it has no schedule at all, which makes question 3 a question for counsel rather than a default to keep everything.
- **The line is about purpose, not records.** The same file can be evidence today and part of an archive tomorrow; the guide decides which question is being asked, not what the file is. The wider split between finding an archive and licensing it is drawn in [the difference between finding archives and licensing them](/guides/the-difference-between-finding-archives-and-licensing-them).

## Next step

> **Refer a company. No cap on rewards.** Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.

Once counsel has released the records and the decider asks for the conversation, [register](/register), compare the decider's own description with [who qualifies](/who-qualifies), and note which version of the [program terms](/terms) applied on the day you sent an introduction with nothing attached.

## Sources

- https://refer.sourcex.si/who-qualifies
- https://refer.sourcex.si/terms
- https://sourcex.si/documents/partner/SourceX_Channel_Partner_Agreement_Sample.pdf
- https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/art_5/oj
