# Route local rules questions to local counsel | SourceX

Canonical: https://refer.sourcex.si/guides/how-to-route-local-rules-questions-without-giving-generic-legal-advice
Last updated: 2026-11-05

Do not answer the question, and do not send back a disclaimer in place of an answer. When someone asks whether their local rules let them introduce a company to SourceX or be paid for it, give them a question pack: their own facts, SourceX's documents as published that day, and the confidentiality, conflict and compensation questions written out. They send it to a reviewer qualified where the rules attach, and you record only the route that returns: a paid referral, an unpaid introduction or no part.

This guide is for alliance managers, practice-group leads and network compliance staff who hear that question from people admitted or licensed in many places. It applies no professional rule to anyone; where it cites a rule-maker, it shows why the answer moves from place to place.

## Why one answer for the whole network is generic advice

A network-wide answer is the usual way a network gives legal advice without meaning to: it fixes one jurisdiction's rules on people governed by another's.

The text most people have in mind is a model. The American Bar Association says its Model Rules of Professional Conduct "serve as models for the ethics rules of most jurisdictions," and its consumer FAQ, in paraphrase, calls the Model Rules and the opinions interpreting them advisory, with each jurisdiction's own rules, laws and court decisions in control.

Which jurisdiction governs is a question of its own. Model Rule 8.5, in paraphrase, applies the rules of the place where the conduct occurred to conduct outside a matter pending before a tribunal, unless its predominant effect falls in another jurisdiction. ABA Formal Opinion 504, as summarized in a search excerpt, lists factors bearing on predominant effect, among them where the client is, where the transaction happens, which law governs, the lawyer's principal office and where the lawyer is admitted. A lawyer admitted in two states, working from a third, for a company in a fourth, has a choice-of-law question before any referral question. And accountants, consultants and financial advisers in the same network answer to their own boards, bodies and employers.

| What gets said | Why it fails | Routed version |
|---|---|---|
| "Lawyers can't take referral fees" | One answer for every jurisdiction and role, which can stop someone whose reviewer would have opened an unpaid route | "I can't apply your rules. Here is the pack; your ethics counsel answers it." |
| "It's fine as long as you disclose" | Treats disclosure as a cure, when it may not settle whether pay is permitted at all | Ask first whether pay is permitted, then in what form it must be disclosed |
| "Check your local rules" | Names no reviewer and carries no facts | Name a kind of reviewer and hand over the pack |
| "Our firm's counsel cleared it" | One firm's answer, for its own people and facts, reused by another member | One pack for each person or firm that would sign as the partner |

## Name the role and the proposed activity before anything else

The role is the asker's relationship to the company: counsel on an open matter, counsel with no open matter, a former adviser, an investor or board member, a non-lawyer on the network's staff, or a firm signing as an entity. SourceX's sample Channel Partner Agreement names the Partner as "[an individual, or entity type and jurisdiction]," so a person or a firm could sign; the pack is filled in for whichever would sign, and again for anyone else who would speak to the CEO.

The activity is one of four rungs, and each adds questions.

| Rung | Proposed activity | What it adds for the reviewer |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mention that SourceX exists, with no company named | Mostly a communications question |
| 2 | Introduce one company's CEO, who has asked for the conversation | Confidentiality and conflict questions about that company |
| 3 | Sign the Channel Partner Agreement and become eligible for a reward | Compensation questions on top of the first two |
| 4 | Promote the program to a group: a client alert, newsletter or panel | Rules for that channel, and for everyone it reaches |

Section 1 of the terms requires the agreement before any introduction is submitted, so a member at rung 2 who might move to rung 3 should have the rung 3 answer first.

## The local counsel question pack

The network hands out parts A to C blank, with part B's documents attached. The asker fills in part A and sends the whole pack to their reviewer, and part D comes back. Nothing in part A has to pass through the network.

| Part | What it holds | Who fills it | Why the reviewer needs it |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Where the rules attach | Admissions and licenses; principal office; where they will speak to the CEO; where the company and CEO are; the relationship to the company; whether the firm acts for it; employer or fund policies; the rung | The asker | To decide which rules govern and which duties apply |
| B. What SourceX publishes | The program terms (version 2026-10-22.2, since replaced by version 2026-11-04), the sample Channel Partner Agreement and the who-qualifies page, each dated | The network, as attachments | So the reviewer reads the documents, not a summary |
| C. The questions | The twelve questions in the next section | The network, as a fixed list | So every reviewer answers the same questions |
| D. The answer record | Reviewer and capacity, date, jurisdiction applied, rule relied on, route, conditions, what reopens it | The reviewer, returned by the asker | So the route can be followed and checked later |

Part B flags the passages reviewers usually need: terms sections 2 (credit), 3 (duplicates), 4 (the reward, the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout with no cap, never calculated on SourceX's fees), 5 (payability) and 9 (the one-year agreement), and sample agreement sections 4.2 (no authority to share a company's records or personal information), 4.5 (publicly naming a partner) and 7.1 (the Partner is not SourceX's agent). A reviewer weighing the client's interest will want section 4 word for word: "The referral reward is paid separately by SourceX and is never deducted from the supplier's agreed compensation." The company receives the same amount with or without a partner.

Two points the documents leave open go to SourceX in writing: how it treats a partner who takes no reward, and how a firm's partner account relates to its people's own accounts. The published terms settle neither, so SourceX decides.

## Confidentiality, conflict and compensation questions, written for the reviewer

Each question asks for an answer and the rule behind it. "Probably fine" is not something part D can record.

**Choice of law**

1. Given part A, which jurisdiction's rules govern each rung I might take?
2. If more than one could, which do you rely on, and why?

**Confidentiality**

3. Would telling SourceX that this company's CEO wants a conversation reveal information relating to a representation or engagement, and whose consent would that need?
4. Did what I know about the company's records come from my work for it?
5. At rung 4, what may I say to a group about clients in general?

**Conflict**

6. If I or my firm could be paid when the company is paid, does that affect advice we give it, now or later, about licensing its records?
7. Does anyone at the firm act on matters touching those records or an agreement with SourceX, and what follows?
8. Does an investor, board or fiduciary role add a duty?

**Compensation**

9. May the person or firm in part A receive a reward tied to the company's payout, and on what conditions?
10. If so, what must the company be told, in what form and when?
11. If not, may I make an unpaid introduction, and does anything else apply?
12. Does an employer, partnership or fund policy claim, share or forbid the payment?

Question 10 is a format question as much as a content one; [when a referral relationship must be disclosed in writing](/guides/when-a-referral-relationship-must-be-disclosed-in-writing) works through it channel by channel.

## Where the pack goes, and what each reviewer can give back

| Reviewer | Can give back | Cannot give back |
|---|---|---|
| The firm's ethics counsel or general counsel | A route applied to the asker's facts, with conditions | An answer for members of other firms |
| Outside ethics counsel engaged by the asker | The same, for individuals and small firms | Advice to the whole network |
| A bar or professional body's ethics service | Pointers to rules, cases and opinions | A ruling on the asker's facts |
| The asker's employer or compliance function | Whether policy allows outside pay or activity | What the professional rules require |
| SourceX | What its documents say, and decisions on points they leave open | Whether the asker's rules permit anything |

The State Bar of California describes its Ethics Hotline, in paraphrase of its FAQ, as a confidential research service whose staff point callers to relevant rules, cases and ethics opinions but give no legal advice or opinions and issue nothing in writing: a good place to find the text, and no substitute for part D.

## Three packs, three routes (Illustrative)

Generic members of one fictional alliance, invented facts, no outcome implied.

**A referral.** A partner at a member firm is admitted where she practices and where her client, a 260-person claims administrator, has its head office; her firm has never worked on anything touching its records. The firm's ethics counsel answers all twelve questions: home-state rules govern, and the firm may sign as the partner on conditions that include a written disclosure before any introduction. Told at a separate meeting, the CEO wants the conversation, and the company applies.

**An unpaid introduction.** A lawyer admitted in two states works from a third; the CEO of a 400-person distributor is a former client. Outside ethics counsel finds that predominant effect points to the distributor's state, where the conditions for pay cannot be met, but that an unpaid introduction is open if nothing from the old engagement is used. The terms are silent on a declined reward, so he asks SourceX in writing first.

**No part.** A member firm advises a 150-person engineering consultancy on the contracts covering its project records. Its general counsel answers question 7 first: the firm stays out and keeps advising. The alliance manager logs one dated line, "no part."

## Record the route and the handoff

The router's log needs five columns and no company name: date sent, kind of reviewer, date part D returned, route, and the event that reopens it. A member on the paid route then registers, signs the Channel Partner Agreement and introduces only a CEO who has asked; one on the unpaid route waits for SourceX's written reply.

Reopen the pack when part A changes: a new matter, a new office or admission, a board seat, a new version of SourceX's terms, a different CEO. Waiting for part D costs nothing under the program's clock, which starts with an introduction, not a question. If the CEO applies directly meanwhile, section 3 means no later introduction is credited, which is an acceptable outcome and a good reason not to rush the review.

## What the pack cannot do

- **It is not a rules review.** For a global network that wants one row per person who could be paid, the [jurisdiction review issue register](/guides/when-local-professional-rules-affect-referral-compensation) names the families of rules each should raise; accountants have their own [service-and-jurisdiction review](/guides/before-an-accountant-accepts-a-referral-reward-check-the-applicable-rules).
- **It does not keep a meeting clean.** A lawyer who raises SourceX mid-matter still has to keep legal advice and referral talk apart, as the [role separation conversation guide](/guides/how-to-separate-legal-advice-from-a-data-referral-discussion) describes.
- **It cannot decide for the company.** The company's CEO decides whether it talks to SourceX and signs for it. For a closed, wound-down or insolvent company the CEO may not be enough, and whoever controls the estate, such as a trustee, receiver or assignee, decides.
- **It cannot settle fit or credit.** SourceX judges fit in its own review against its published criteria. One partner can be credited per company, from dated records; where two members know the same company, SourceX resolves it in duplicate review, and a link click settles nothing.

## Next step

> **Refer a company. No cap on rewards.** Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.

Once part D comes back with a paid or unpaid route, [register as a partner](/register), set the CEO's own answers beside [who qualifies](/who-qualifies) and file the [program terms](/terms) version your reviewer read with the answer; more professional workflows sit in the [guides hub](/guides).

## Sources

- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/
- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/resources/resources_for_the_public/consumer_faqs/
- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_8_5_disciplinary_authority_choice_of_law/
- https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/professional_responsibility/ethics-opinions/aba-formal-opinion-504.pdf
- https://www.calbar.ca.gov/legal-professionals/legal-resource-center/ethics/ethics-hotline/frequently-asked-questions-ethics-hotline-service
- https://refer.sourcex.si/terms
- https://sourcex.si/documents/partner/SourceX_Channel_Partner_Agreement_Sample.pdf
- https://refer.sourcex.si/who-qualifies
