# Unfinished rights review referral: handoff memo | SourceX

Canonical: https://refer.sourcex.si/guides/how-to-refer-a-company-while-its-rights-review-is-unfinished
Last updated: 2026-11-04

You can refer a company before its own rights review is finished, as long as the introduction reports status and nothing more. SourceX's published process runs a Rights step with the company and its counsel, and its guidance allows scoping in stages, so open items are expected. Send a qualified inquiry handoff memo: each record family marked clear, pending or out in the CEO's words, who holds each open item, and none of counsel's reasoning. If your own firm runs the review, settle your role with ethics counsel first.

This page is for law firm alliance managers and regulated advisers whose client is partway through checking what it may license. If nobody has started that check yet, the earlier step is [the counsel handoff note](/guides/how-to-refer-a-client-whose-data-rights-need-legal-review). Nothing here is legal advice to the company or a view on whether your profession lets you accept a reward.

## Unfinished is the normal state of a rights review

A rights review rarely ends in a single yes. SourceX's insight on the subject describes six areas (ownership, customer contracts, vendor terms, employee and contractor records, third-party content and prior licenses) and says the output is a scope: what is in, what is in only after redaction, what is out. Asked whether a company can start before every contract is found, it answers: "Yes, by scoping in stages. Records whose rights are clear can proceed, while records tied to missing contracts wait."

The review also has a fixed place in SourceX's process. "Rights is the second step of the SourceX five-step transaction, after Supply and before Preparation. SourceX works through the checklist with the company and its counsel." The company's own work feeds that step rather than replacing it, and the same page adds that "The company decides the final scope and approves it before preparation begins." The first step asks for nothing physical: SourceX describes it as "A few questions, no files", and says no records are shared at that stage.

So an unfinished internal review is not a reason to hold back by itself. What an introduction must not do is turn an open question into a closed one.

## Who runs the review sets your first move

The same unfinished review means different things depending on whose desk it sits on.

| Who is running it | What that makes you | First move | Usual ending |
|---|---|---|---|
| The company's in-house counsel | A messenger of status | Ask the CEO what may be said, then draft the memo | Referral, or an unpaid introduction if your rules require it |
| Outside counsel at another firm | A messenger of status | Same, with counsel's status relayed through the CEO | Referral, or an unpaid introduction |
| Your own firm, on an engagement for the company | An adviser on the question a reward would pay for | Ethics counsel before you say a word to the CEO | Unpaid introduction, a colleague's introduction or no part |
| Nobody yet, or stalled with no owner | Too early for this memo | Use the counsel handoff note instead | Introduction later, once someone owns the review |
| The company is in a wind-down or formal process | Unsure who decides | Find who controls the estate; the CEO may not be enough | Depends on that controller |

## The qualified inquiry handoff memo

The memo is one page, written for the CEO to approve and send or for you to submit with the CEO's written agreement. It is called qualified because every line carries its own limit: what the company knows today, who is still working on what, and what nobody has decided. It reports, it never argues.

| Field | What it says | Who supplies it | Never in it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Request | "The CEO asked me to introduce the company while its rights review continues", with the date | You, from the CEO's words | Your view of the opportunity |
| 2. Record families | Type of record, system, years covered and who created them | The CEO | Counts pulled from systems, samples, screenshots |
| 3. Status per family | Clear, pending or out, as the company's counsel lets the CEO state it | The CEO | Your own reading of any document |
| 4. Open item category | For pending families: which of the six review areas is open | The CEO | Customer names, clause text, counsel's analysis |
| 5. Holder of each open item | In-house counsel, outside counsel, or the CEO personally | The CEO | A promised completion date |
| 6. What the company expects | The CEO's own words on timing, marked as theirs | The CEO | Your estimate |
| 7. Your role and any pay | Who may pay you, that the company's payout is the same either way, where your own rules check stands | You | A claim that your advice is independent if it is not |
| 8. What happens next | The company applies itself and describes its records to SourceX | You | Any term, price or scope promise |

## Why the memo stays thinner than the review

Field 7 rests on section 4 of the terms: the reward is paid separately by SourceX and never comes out of the company's agreed compensation, so the company receives the same amount with or without you. Field 8 rests on section 7.1 of the sample partner agreement, which says a partner is not SourceX's agent and may not commit it to prices, licenses or payouts.

Fields 3 to 5 carry the weight. SourceX's own page notes that buyers usually see the outcome of a review rather than the internal memo, "which may be privileged". Your memo should be even thinner than that outcome: a status word and a category, never the why.

## Status lines that inform, and lines that overpromise

The memo fails when a status word slides into a conclusion. These pairs show the difference. The last pair matters more than it looks: SourceX's how-it-works page lists among the supplier's confirmations that the data "hasn't been licensed for AI training before", so data already licensed for AI training is out, and no further review brings it back.

| Write | Never write | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Support tickets: clear, per company counsel, as relayed by the CEO | The support tickets are cleared for licensing | Only SourceX's process and the signed agreements fix a scope |
| Customer project files: pending, customer contracts under review | Customer contracts look fine | You have not read them, and should not |
| Records of the 2019 acquisition: pending, purchase papers being located | The acquisition records came with the deal | Ownership is one of the six review areas |
| Field service notes: out for now, per the CEO | Field notes can be added later | Whether anything returns is the company's decision |
| Expected timing: "this quarter", the CEO's words | Rights will be done by March | A date you set becomes a promise you cannot keep |
| Earlier licensing: the CEO says none of this data was licensed for AI training | No prior licenses exist | The supplier gives that confirmation in its own agreement |

## When the reviewer is your own firm

The memo is easy when someone else is doing the review. It is hard when your firm is counsel on it, because a reward tied to the company licensing gives you a reason to want a "clear" in field 3.

**Confidentiality.** Model Rule 1.6(a) reads: "A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client gives informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized in order to carry out the representation or the disclosure is permitted by paragraph (b)." Even a status word about a review your firm is running is information relating to the representation. Ask ethics counsel what consent covers it.

**Conflict.** The comment to Model Rule 1.7 says: "The lawyer's own interests should not be permitted to have an adverse effect on representation of a client." Whether a possible reward is such an interest on your facts, and what follows, is your ethics counsel's call. The [client conflict check](/guides/the-client-conflict-check-before-a-data-introduction) lists the parties to run first, and [separating legal advice from the referral discussion](/guides/how-to-separate-legal-advice-from-a-data-referral-discussion) covers which hat you wear in the room.

**Compensation.** This page does not say whether you may be paid. Bring your rule-maker's own text to your counsel. If the answer is to take nothing, the published terms say nothing about a partner who declines a reward, so tell SourceX before you submit and let it decide how to record that.

Compliance consultants and privacy officers who are not lawyers face the same three questions under their own codes, employers and engagement letters.

## The review's clock and the attribution window run separately

Section 2 of the terms reads: "The first valid introduction of a new company within the 90-day attribution window receives credit when that company submits a verified application." The sample agreement puts the same window at 90 days from the recorded introduction, and the terms add that "The 90-day window does not extend because contact protection under the agreement continues."

Nothing published ties that window to a company's internal review. If the CEO wants counsel to finish before applying, the honest options are to introduce now and accept that the window may close before an application, or to wait and introduce later. Credit is SourceX's decision from dated records either way. Never press a CEO to apply early so that your credit survives.

## A distributor, a clinic network and a software firm, mid-review (Illustrative)

Illustrative. Generic companies, invented facts, no outcomes implied.

**A 260-person distributor, outside counsel reviewing.** The owner-CEO tells her consultant that order and returns records are clear, that customer-specific pricing files are pending a review of customer contracts, and that records from a 2019 acquisition wait on the purchase papers. The consultant is not counsel and acts for no party. The memo lists five families with three statuses, names outside counsel as holder of both open items and quotes the CEO's "next quarter". The consultant's own rules check has come back, and the CEO asks for the introduction. Referral.

**A 400-person clinic network, the referrer's firm reviewing.** A law firm is counsel on the network's review, and its alliance manager sees the fit. Ethics counsel's written view: the firm takes no reward while it advises on rights, and status words leave only with the CEO's informed consent. The CEO sends the memo herself and applies; the firm is named as nothing. Unpaid introduction.

**A 150-person software firm, review finished early.** Counsel finds that the core ticket archive was licensed to an AI developer two years ago, and the remaining records sit mostly in customer tenants. The CEO and the adviser agree there is nothing to introduce now. No introduction, and a dated note of why.

## Questions a status memo leaves to SourceX

Before any memo, the company should plausibly fit: a full-time headcount that reached 50 at its high point (contractors do not count), a history of records it made itself, and a CEO who wants the conversation. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English. Material that belongs to the company's clients is on SourceX's usual-poor-fit list. The person submitting signs the Channel Partner Agreement first. A vendor or IT provider fielding a rights question rather than advising on it should follow [the customer rights routing guide](/guides/how-to-route-a-customer-s-data-rights-question-to-their-own-team). Even with every family marked clear, these stay open:

- Whether the records match SourceX's current data needs, which it assesses in review.
- The final scope, which the company approves before preparation and fixes in its signed agreements.
- Anything about price or payout, which the memo never mentions.
- Whether the company counts as new to SourceX: earlier email, a lead or an account makes it a duplicate under section 3.

## Next step

> **Refer a company. No cap on rewards.** Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.

When the CEO has approved a status-only memo and your own role is settled, [register as a partner](/register), compare the company with [who qualifies](/who-qualifies) and read the [program terms](/terms) on the attribution window before anything is submitted; related professional guides are in the [guides hub](/guides).

## Sources

- https://sourcex.si/insights/what-is-a-data-rights-review-and-what-does-it-check
- https://sourcex.si/how-it-works
- https://refer.sourcex.si/terms
- https://refer.sourcex.si/who-qualifies
- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_6_confidentiality_of_information/
- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_7_conflict_of_interest_current_clients/comment_on_rule_1_7/
- https://sourcex.si/documents/partner/SourceX_Channel_Partner_Agreement_Sample.pdf
