# Keep privileged material out of data referrals | SourceX

Canonical: https://refer.sourcex.si/guides/how-to-keep-privileged-material-out-of-data-referral-discussions
Last updated: 2026-11-04

Keep the referral to facts the CEO would state in an ordinary business conversation, and send everything else back to the company's counsel. Privileged and matter material slips into a referral in six places: where the idea came from, the introduction message, the first call, documents someone volunteers, the introducer's own notes and the company's application. The checklist below sets two checks at each, names what can travel instead, and leaves every judgment about what is privileged with the company's counsel, which is how SourceX's own guidance on legal material reads.

This page is for lawyers, law firm alliance managers and other regulated advisors who might mention SourceX to a client. It gives no view on privilege or waiver under any law; it keeps a referral from ever needing one.

## Privilege, confidentiality and a referral are three different things

The American Bar Association's comment to Model Rule 1.6 names three related bodies of law that give effect to client confidentiality: "the attorney-client privilege, the work product doctrine and the rule of confidentiality established in professional ethics." In our paraphrase of that comment, the first two apply when evidence is sought from a lawyer in proceedings, while the ethics rule reaches further, to all information relating to the representation, whatever its source. A further comment says the rule also covers disclosures that do not themselves reveal protected information but "could reasonably lead to the discovery of such information by a third person." Your state's version of the rule governs.

SourceX's guidance on legal material is shorter: "Anything covered by legal privilege or ongoing disputes is excluded. Your counsel decides what counts."

A referral needs none of it. The categories below are for recognizing material, not for classifying it; the introducer never decides which side of a legal line something falls on.

| Kind of material | How it tends to appear around a referral | Who decides what it is | What the referral does with it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal advice | Counsel's view on whether customer contracts allow reuse of records | The company's counsel | Never quoted, summarized or alluded to |
| Work prepared for a dispute | A memo or analysis about the records made for litigation | The company's counsel | Left out entirely |
| Matter information | That a dispute, inquiry or litigation hold exists | The company's counsel; for a lawyer, also their own ethics counsel | Left out entirely |
| Business facts the CEO offers | Headcount band, years in operation, kinds of systems | The CEO | Travels only with the CEO's agreement, and for a lawyer only as client-information rules allow |

What a lawyer may pass on about a client at all is for the lawyer's own confidentiality rules and ethics counsel to decide.

## The privilege-preserving introduction checklist

| Point of contact | Check | What can travel instead |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Where the idea came from | 1a. Could you describe the opportunity from what the CEO has said, or would say, outside any matter? If you know about the records only because you advised on them, the idea waits until the CEO raises it or ethics counsel says how to proceed | The CEO's own words, dated |
| 1. Where the idea came from | 1b. Are the records you would mention under a hold, in a dispute or the subject of advice? SourceX excludes ongoing disputes, so they are not a referral subject | Records the CEO names that touch no open matter |
| 2. The introduction message | 2a. No matter names, no "as we discussed on the dispute", no counsel's views, no hint that legal questions exist | The company, the CEO's contact details, the CEO's agreement |
| 2. The introduction message | 2b. Records appear only by type, system and span, as the CEO described them; no figures learned in the engagement | "Maintenance tickets in its work-order system since 2013" |
| 3. The first call | 3a. The agenda covers SourceX's published process, the published fit facts and who decides, never the company's legal position on its rights | SourceX's own pages, linked |
| 3. The first call | 3b. If anyone starts relaying legal advice, the introducer suggests the company and its counsel take that up separately; whether counsel joins is the company's call | A note that a rights question exists, routed to the company's counsel |
| 4. Documents someone volunteers | 4a. A memo, a contract with counsel's comments or a hold notice offered "so SourceX understands" is declined and never forwarded; SourceX's first step needs no files | The reply: "SourceX asks the company a few questions and needs no documents" |
| 4. Documents someone volunteers | 4b. If something arrives anyway: stop forwarding it, tell the company's counsel what arrived and when, and leave every next step to counsel | The date and the fact that counsel was told |
| 5. Notes and the referral log | 5a. The log holds dates, roles, decisions and the next step; no summaries of advice, no matter names, no attachments | "Rights question, routed to company counsel, day 12" |
| 5. Notes and the referral log | 5b. A note may record that a legal question exists and where it went, never what it says | The question type and its recipient |
| 6. The company's application | 6a. The company describes its own records to SourceX; the introducer neither drafts nor reviews that description | Nothing from the introducer |
| 6. The company's application | 6b. Legal folders, counsel threads and anything under a hold stay out of scope; SourceX's guidance asks the company to have counsel list privileged sources, check for litigation holds and exclude legal folders, with counsel signing off on the exclusions | The company's own scope, set with its counsel |

Point 2 matters more than it looks. SourceX's terms say attribution is decided from dated records, including written introduction evidence, so the introduction message is a document that may be read again later. It should be one you would be content for anyone to read.

Point 4 has a backstop in SourceX's sample partner agreement, which "gives Partner no authority to share a supplier's inventory, records, raw data or personal information, or to access extraction systems." SourceX's partner process page adds that a partner does not need to export, upload or describe confidential records.

## Review questions on confidentiality, conflict and compensation

Bring these to your ethics counsel, or for an alliance manager to the firm's general counsel, before the first mention.

- **Confidentiality.** Did anything that prompted the idea come from the representation, the firm's matter list or a client's files? If so, what may be said, and with whose consent?
- **Conflict.** Would the introduction put you, or the firm, on both sides of the same records, advising the company about them while the company discusses them with SourceX?
- **Compensation.** If a reward is possible, has ethics counsel reviewed it? A client who asks about it is covered in [answering a client's question about the reward](/guides/when-a-lawyer-s-client-asks-about-the-referral-reward).
- **Records policy.** Where should the referral note live so that it stays out of matter files and legal work product?

How to hold the referral conversation apart from legal advice is covered in [separating legal advice from a referral discussion](/guides/how-to-separate-legal-advice-from-a-data-referral-discussion), and carrying a CEO's rights doubts to the company's own lawyer in [the counsel handoff note](/guides/how-to-refer-a-client-whose-data-rights-need-legal-review).

## Three introductions run through the checklist (Illustrative)

Generic companies and invented facts; no outcome is implied for any real company.

**A referral.** A litigator's firm represents a 240-person property manager in a lease dispute. At a business dinner the CEO says, unprompted, that the company has kept maintenance tickets for eleven years and wonders whether they could be licensed. Check 1a passes because the CEO raised it outside the matter; check 1b passes because the tickets have nothing to do with the dispute. Ethics counsel reviews the facts and the firm signs the Channel Partner Agreement as the partner. The introduction names the work-order system and its span and nothing else. The dispute never appears in the message, the log or the call.

**An unpaid introduction.** An alliance manager at another firm mentions SourceX to a client's general counsel, who replies with counsel's memo on customer contract restrictions "to help SourceX." Check 4a applies: the alliance manager does not open it further or forward it, and tells the general counsel that SourceX needs no documents. Because the firm advises on those same contracts, ethics counsel's answer leads the firm to take no reward. The published terms do not address a partner who declines one, so the firm asks SourceX in writing, records the reply, and then introduces the CEO.

**No part at all.** A privacy lawyer learned about a 400-person company's call recordings only while advising it on a data incident. The CEO has never raised licensing. Check 1a fails, so there is no introduction and nothing is said. If the CEO raises the idea independently later, the lawyer starts again at check 1a with ethics counsel.

## What a clean referral still has to carry

A referral without any matter material still needs the published fit facts, confirmed by the CEO: at least 50 full-time employees at the company's peak, contractors left out; years of records the company made itself; authority to license that material; and a CEO who has asked to talk. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English. Records the company holds for its clients rarely fit, since they are the clients' material, and whether customer contracts allow reuse is decided in SourceX's review with the company's counsel, never in the referral. Whoever submits signs the Channel Partner Agreement first. More professional workflows are in the [guides hub](/guides).

This is general information, not legal advice. Privilege and confidentiality questions belong to the company's counsel and to your own ethics counsel.

## Next step

> **Refer a company. No cap on rewards.** Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.

When every check on the list passes and the CEO has asked for the conversation, confirm the company against [who qualifies](/who-qualifies), read the [program terms](/terms) on how introductions are recorded and [register as a partner](/register) before you send a message you would be content for anyone to read.

## Sources

- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_6_confidentiality_of_information/comment_on_rule_1_6/
- https://sourcex.si/guides/privileged-material-data-licensing
- https://refer.sourcex.si/how-it-works
- https://sourcex.si/how-it-works
- https://refer.sourcex.si/terms
- https://sourcex.si/documents/partner/SourceX_Channel_Partner_Agreement_Sample.pdf
- https://refer.sourcex.si/who-qualifies
