# Professional association data panel: moderation | SourceX

Canonical: https://refer.sourcex.si/guides/a-data-partnership-panel-hosted-by-a-professional-association
Last updated: 2026-11-04

Run the panel as a room full of people who hold other people's confidences. Before the day, every speaker puts their tie to SourceX in writing, and a speaker who is a SourceX partner gets SourceX's written permission before naming it on stage. During the panel, the moderator turns client detail into generic terms, sends every "am I allowed?" to the member's own ethics counsel and keeps prices off the table. Afterward, the association passes no attendee list to anyone, and members act for themselves.

This guide is for the alliance manager, program chair or section leader who moderates, and for regulated members who speak, at a live or streamed panel hosted by a bar section, an accountancy society chapter, a compliance network or a similar body. It applies no professional rule. It gives the moderator lines to use and places to send each question. A session built from members' own questions is covered by [the chamber workshop agenda](/guides/the-chamber-workshop-that-starts-with-company-questions), and an opening module on who is unlikely to fit by [the member webinar cards](/guides/a-member-webinar-should-include-who-is-unlikely-to-qualify).

## Who sits on the stage, and what each seat may say

A panel mixes people with different interests in front of an audience that cannot tell them apart. Fix each seat's scope before anyone speaks.

| Seat | May speak to | Leaves alone | Opening disclosure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moderator, for the association | The format, the house rules and where each question goes | Any view on whether licensing suits a member's client | Whether the association receives anything from SourceX, for this session or as a partner |
| SourceX speaker | What SourceX publishes: its process, its program terms, its fit criteria | Members' professional rules; any company's chances; who buys; figures SourceX has not published | Employed or engaged by SourceX |
| Member who is a registered partner | Their own practice: how they raise the subject with a CEO, what they never handle | Their clients, in any form a listener could recognize; what other members may do | That SourceX may pay them for introductions, and that SourceX authorized them to say so publicly |
| Independent member, such as ethics or privacy counsel | General questions a member should take to their own adviser | Rulings for anyone in the room | Any tie to SourceX, or none |

Leave out a company describing its own licensing deal. SourceX's process page says "Neither side publicizes the deal," and a panel is a public setting.

The association's own position needs one sentence at the opening: it is hosting a discussion, not endorsing a provider. Nothing said on stage should suggest that members' clients will qualify, that SourceX endorses the association, that anyone gains preferential access to a company's data, or that the association can decide anything for a company. Each company's CEO decides whether it talks to SourceX.

## Before the day: a disclosure roster and three permissions

**The roster.** Each speaker writes one line: who pays them, whether SourceX pays or may pay them, and any client relationship that bears on the topic. The moderator reads the roster at the start, the first slide shows it, and it stays in any recording or clip; reuse rules are in [reusing a webinar without misrepresenting live questions](/guides/how-to-reuse-a-webinar-without-misrepresenting-live-questions). The form each speaker's disclosure must take is a question for that speaker's reviewer, broken down in [when a referral relationship must be disclosed in writing](/guides/when-a-referral-relationship-must-be-disclosed-in-writing).

**Permission 1: SourceX's, for naming the relationship.** Section 4.5 of the sample Channel Partner Agreement reads: "Neither Party may publicly identify the other as a partner or disclose non-public deal details without written authorization, except as legally required." A partner who plans to say "I am a SourceX partner" on stage needs that authorization in writing first.

**Permission 2: each regulated speaker's own clearance.** Speaking about a program that may pay you, in front of clients and peers, raises confidentiality, conflict and compensation questions only the speaker's ethics counsel or compliance function can answer. The [local counsel question pack](/guides/how-to-route-local-rules-questions-without-giving-generic-legal-advice) carries those questions; rung 4 in it covers promotion to a group.

**Permission 3: the association's own policies.** Its sponsorship or endorsement policy decides how SourceX may appear. Where members' businesses compete with one another, its antitrust statement belongs at the opening too.

Slides cite their sources, and any reward figure follows the published terms: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap, payable only when the conditions in section 5 are met. Section 5 also says "A lead, meeting or signed agreement alone does not earn a payable reward," which belongs on the same slide.

## The live-question cards

Lawyers in the room carry a duty that makes the first card necessary. Comment [4] to ABA Model Rule 1.6 says: "A lawyer's use of a hypothetical to discuss issues relating to the representation is permissible so long as there is no reasonable likelihood that the listener will be able to ascertain the identity of the client or the situation involved." ABA Formal Opinion 511R, which applies that comment to questions posted on lawyer listservs, adds, in paraphrase of a search excerpt, that a general question is less likely to identify a client than a hypothetical that reproduces the facts, that the more unusual the situation the greater the risk, and that a lawyer should err on the side of caution. A live audience is not a listserv, accountants and consultants answer to their own rules, and the moderator decides nothing about anyone's duty. The moderator can still borrow the caution.

| Card | When you hear | Moderator's line | Where it goes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A member describes a client by size, town, system or years | "Let's keep it general: the kind of record and roughly how old, no company and no place." | The generic version only; specifics stay between the member and that CEO |
| 2 | "Would my client qualify?" | "Nobody on this stage can say. SourceX publishes its fit criteria and decides in its own review." | The [who-qualifies page](/who-qualifies), read by the client's CEO |
| 3 | "As a lawyer, or a CPA, may I take the reward?" | "That turns on rules none of us can apply for you. Take it to your own ethics counsel." | The member's own reviewer |
| 4 | "What did SourceX pay a company like ours?" or "What were you offered?" | SourceX: "A payout is fixed only in the company's own signed Dataset Deal Confirmation, and deals are not publicized." Moderator: "Members don't share offers or terms here." | Nowhere on stage |
| 5 | "Who buys the data?" | SourceX: "The Acquisition Partner's identity may stay confidential." | Nowhere on stage |
| 6 | "Can I give you my card so you can call my client?" | "SourceX hears from a company's CEO, or from a partner that CEO asked to make the introduction, not from a card about someone else." | The member asks the CEO first, privately |
| 7 | "Is the association recommending this?" | "We are hosting a discussion, not endorsing a provider. Each member and each company decides for itself." | The association's policy |
| 8 | "If two of us know the same company, who gets the credit?" | "Only one partner can be credited per company. SourceX settles overlaps from dated records in duplicate review, a link click decides nothing, and nobody here rules on it." | Sections 2 and 3 of the [program terms](/terms) |

Give the moderator one stop phrase that needs no explanation, such as "Let's hold that one; it belongs with your own adviser," and the authority to use it mid-sentence. Card 5 rests on section 1.9 of the sample agreement, which says an Acquisition Partner's "identity and contract may remain confidential."

## Confidentiality, conflict and compensation questions each speaker settles beforehand

- **Confidentiality.** How much of my practice's experience may I describe at all? Could anyone in the room work out which client I mean from what I plan to say?
- **Conflict.** Does speaking for a program that may pay me sit badly with clients in the audience, or with my firm's other clients?
- **Compensation.** Must I disclose that SourceX may pay me, and in which forms: spoken, on a slide, in the printed program, in the recording?

A speaker who cannot get answers before the day speaks only as an independent member or does not speak.

## After the panel: what the association keeps and what it never sends

| Item | The association keeps | It never sends to SourceX |
|---|---|---|
| Attendee list | Under its own privacy policy | In any form |
| Questions asked | In generic form, without names, for its own planning | Any question that points to a company |
| Follow-up requests | From members who asked, answered with SourceX's public pages | Names or details of members' clients |
| Recording | Only with speakers' and attendees' consent, roster included | Clips that cut the disclosures |

Members who want to take part register on their own, and introduce only a CEO who asked; SourceX's own first step is "A few questions, no files," so nobody needs anything from a member's file. The opt-in pattern behind this table is set out in [offering a referral program without selling your member list](/guides/how-to-offer-a-referral-program-without-selling-your-member-list).

## Three members after the panel (Illustrative)

Generic members and invented facts; no outcome implied.

**A referral.** An employment lawyer in the audience had already been cleared by her firm's ethics counsel and registered as a partner. At a client meeting weeks later she asks the CEO of a 220-person staffing firm whether he would like to hear about SourceX, and he says yes. She gives the disclosure in the form her reviewer set. Only the firm's own full-time staff count toward the size threshold, not the workers it places with clients, so she notes both figures separately and introduces the firm anyway because its records are long and its own.

**An unpaid introduction.** An accountant's reviewer rules out a reward for her. Because the published terms do not say how SourceX treats a partner who declines one, she asks SourceX in writing, keeps the reply, and then introduces a client CEO who asked, telling him she will take nothing and that the company's amount is the same either way, as section 4 of the terms provides.

**No part.** A compliance consultant's firm advises one of its clients on the contracts that cover that client's records. She decides to stay out of referrals altogether and asks nothing further. The association records nothing about her decision.

## Where a careful panel still goes wrong

- **Clips travel.** A thirty-second excerpt can drop the roster. Consent and editing rules decide whether a recording exists at all.
- **Identifiability is hard to judge live.** A moderator who is not a lawyer should cut early rather than weigh whether a detail is too specific.
- **Enthusiasm reads as endorsement.** A partner speaker's success stories sound like the association's view. The roster helps; it does not cure it.
- **A panel teaches nobody their rules.** Members leave with routes to their own advisers, not answers.
- **The company still decides.** Its CEO authorizes any licensing discussion. For a closed, wound-down or insolvent company the CEO may not be enough, and whoever controls the estate, such as a trustee, receiver or assignee, decides. Companies in the U.S., Canada and the EU qualify, as do companies in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa, Latin America, the UAE and Saudi Arabia when at least 70% of the data is in English.

## Next step

> **Refer a company. No cap on rewards.** Default reward on a company's first qualifying transaction: the greater of $50,000 plus 5% and 15% of Actual Supplier Payout, with no cap; further qualifying transactions first agreed within 12 months of the first Closing pay 15%. Eligibility and payment conditions apply, including the USD 100,000 Minimum Transaction, and a signed Schedule A or addendum can differ. A lead, meeting or signature alone does not trigger payment.

A member who leaves the panel with a client CEO in mind should settle their own rules first, then [register](/register), let the CEO compare the company with [who qualifies](/who-qualifies) and read the [program terms](/terms) on credit; other professional guides sit in the [guides hub](/guides).

## Sources

- https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_1_6_confidentiality_of_information/comment_on_rule_1_6/
- https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/professional_responsibility/ethics-opinions/aba-formal-opinion-511r.pdf
- https://sourcex.si/documents/partner/SourceX_Channel_Partner_Agreement_Sample.pdf
- https://sourcex.si/how-it-works
- https://refer.sourcex.si/terms
- https://refer.sourcex.si/who-qualifies
